The very two words that signify the titles of the two portions of the Torah that we will hear in shul this Shabbat are, at first glance, contradictory. Nitzavim signifies a solid stance, unwavering presence, and a commanding appearance. It reflects an unchanging nature, and the necessary ability to stand one’s ground no matter what the circumstances of life.
On the other hand, the word Vayelech signifies motion, progress, change and a forward thrust in behavior and concepts.
It seems that these two Torah readings cancel each other out, for one signifies unchanging steadfastness while the other champions progress, change and motion. Such an understanding of Torah and Judaism is very superficial and erroneous.
Rather, the two traits indicated in the opening words of these two Torah readings essentially complement each other. They do not come to point out a disagreement, one with another, but to point out that Judaism requires both traits to be present within every Jewish individual and the Jewish people as a whole so that Torah and tradition will survive and prosper in Jewish society.
An important and necessary part of our Jewish character and that of Jewish society is our stubbornness – our refusal to abandon what we have been commanded by the L-rd to observe and practice. This commitment can never be modified or adjusted, acceding to the passing social norms and changing human mores.
We are witness, in our times, how quickly acceptable human behavior and ideas can rapidly change, so that what was unthinkable and perverse a few short decades ago is today not only acceptable but behavior that should be championed, admired, and, in some cases, even enforced legally against ones wishes.
At the same time, Jewish society cannot remain eternally frozen and incapable of adjustment to new situations and differing societal changes. Our recent experience with the coronavirus, with the various halachic responses to it concerning prayer services, study sessions and personal behavior, testify to the adaptability that the Torah and Jewish tradition, dating back to Sinai, has built-in in order to be able to deal with all possible situations, no matter how unforeseen.
The only question that remains is how to achieve a proper balance between Nitzavim and Vayelech. We are witness to the fact that helter-skelter progress and the adoption of new norms leads to spiritual destruction and is an enormous danger to Jewish survival. On the other hand, we certainly need to recognize that 21st-century Israel or the United States is not the same as 19th century eastern and central Europe. Every individual, as well as every group within Jewish society, must feel its way slowly and carefully to try and find the proper balance that fits them and allows them to retain the blessings of tradition and faithfulness, while still dealing with current problems and situations. Understandably, this process is an ongoing one, and it is one of great delicacy and nuance. Nevertheless, it is part of our drive for eternity and the enhancement of our religious society.
Shabbat shalom.
Categorised in: Torah Thought
